Jane declines St. John's offer to go to India as his wife because she does not want to marry him. Although she fears the possibility of dying in India as a missionary, her greater fear is the loveless life guaranteed by marriage to St. John.In six weeks, St. John will leave for India, and he wants Jane to accompany him, as his wife. If she goes to India, Jane knows she'll die prematurely, but she agrees to go anyway — if she can go as his sister, not his wife, because they don't love each other as husband and wife should.He tells Jane that God formed Jane "for labour, not for love," and that she has no "personal, but mental endowments." St. John means that Jane's nature and personality is suited to being a hardworking, chaste, self-sacrificing missionary's wife.
What does St. John symbolize in Jane Eyre : St John Rivers represents to Jane a form of Christianity that enforces the suppression of deep human emotion, and the absolute devotion to the duty given by God without the interference of personal agency.
Why does Jane choose Rochester over St. John
Jane marries Rochester because she views him as her emotional home. From the start of the novel, Jane struggles to find people she can connect with emotionally. Although she nominally has a home at Gateshead, she describes herself as being a “discord” there, temperamentally alienated from the Reeds.
Why does Jane refuse to marry Rochester : But living with Rochester as his mistress would require a self-compromise that Jane is not willing to make. Even before she learns of Bertha's existence, Jane senses that in marrying Rochester she risks cementing herself into a position of inequality.
John tells Jane she has admirable qualities, and proposes that she marry him and accompany him on his missionary work. But Jane's "heart is mute." She recognizes that she could never be happy as St. John's wife. She tells him she would only go to work in India as his sister.
I forgive him at the moment, and on the spot" (298). In Moor House, after her quarrel with St. John over their different understandings of marriage, Jane wishes to believe that he is "superior to the mean gratification of vengeance" and that "he had forgiven me for saying I scorned him and his love" (410).
Does St John fall in love with Jane
St John's marriage proposal to Jane is made without love and passion – he presents it as a job, not as a relationship. He is very cold when he describes how he feels about Jane, suggesting that she was formed for God's work and not for love, implying that no one will love her.As she is about to accept St. John's wishes, Jane experiences a sensation as "sharp, as strange, as shocking" as an electric shock. Then she hears Rochester's voice calling her name. So powerful is this voice that Jane cries, "I am coming," and runs out the door into the garden, but she discovers no sign of Rochester.Jane refuses to marry St. John because she does not love him, but St. John pressures Jane to ignore her feelings and submit to his powerful conception of necessary moral duty.
St John's marriage proposal to Jane is made without love and passion – he presents it as a job, not as a relationship. He is very cold when he describes how he feels about Jane, suggesting that she was formed for God's work and not for love, implying that no one will love her.
Why didn t Jane want to marry Rochester : She fears that Rochester would objectify her and that by “marrying above her station” she would come to the relationship already “in debt” to him. Now Jane sees more clearly than ever that a relationship with Rochester would mean the loss of her self-respect, and of her control over her life.
What is the age gap between Jane and Rochester : Rochester is 37, Jane Eyre is 18. This is even mentioned in the book as a major age gap (see chapter 36, "Mr. Rochester was about forty, and this governess not twenty; and you see, when gentlemen of his age fall in love with girls, they are often like as if they were bewitched. Well, he would marry her.").
What is the age difference between Jane Eyre and Rochester
Rochester is 37, Jane Eyre is 18. This is even mentioned in the book as a major age gap (see chapter 36, "Mr. Rochester was about forty, and this governess not twenty; and you see, when gentlemen of his age fall in love with girls, they are often like as if they were bewitched. Well, he would marry her.").
John is a dangerous influence on her, because his forceful personality compels her obedience against her own internal feelings. Jane refuses to marry St. John because she does not love him, but St. John pressures Jane to ignore her feelings and submit to his powerful conception of necessary moral duty.Rosamund Oliver
John does not love Jane. He wants to marry her just because he thinks she would make a good missionary's wife because of her intelligence,dedication and virtues. He loves Rosamund Oliver passionately,but doesn't want to marry her because he thinks she is unsuited for the work of a missionary's wife.
Should Jane have ended up with St John : It is simply not right for Jane to conjoin herself with such a force. Although her true love, Rochester, is at this stage not right for her either – he is still bound to his wife, and has much to atone for in his past before he can belong to Jane – it is clear that she cannot choose St. John Rivers.
![Kladsko-5-malý-Karlův-Most[1]](https://www.einarstrayorchestra.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Kladsko-5-maly-Karluv-Most1-1024x692-250x120.jpg)
![Stubai[1]](https://www.einarstrayorchestra.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Stubai1-250x120.jpg)
Antwort Why didn t Jane want to marry St John? Weitere Antworten – Why does Jane Eyre refuse to marry St. John
Jane declines St. John's offer to go to India as his wife because she does not want to marry him. Although she fears the possibility of dying in India as a missionary, her greater fear is the loveless life guaranteed by marriage to St. John.In six weeks, St. John will leave for India, and he wants Jane to accompany him, as his wife. If she goes to India, Jane knows she'll die prematurely, but she agrees to go anyway — if she can go as his sister, not his wife, because they don't love each other as husband and wife should.He tells Jane that God formed Jane "for labour, not for love," and that she has no "personal, but mental endowments." St. John means that Jane's nature and personality is suited to being a hardworking, chaste, self-sacrificing missionary's wife.
What does St. John symbolize in Jane Eyre : St John Rivers represents to Jane a form of Christianity that enforces the suppression of deep human emotion, and the absolute devotion to the duty given by God without the interference of personal agency.
Why does Jane choose Rochester over St. John
Jane marries Rochester because she views him as her emotional home. From the start of the novel, Jane struggles to find people she can connect with emotionally. Although she nominally has a home at Gateshead, she describes herself as being a “discord” there, temperamentally alienated from the Reeds.
Why does Jane refuse to marry Rochester : But living with Rochester as his mistress would require a self-compromise that Jane is not willing to make. Even before she learns of Bertha's existence, Jane senses that in marrying Rochester she risks cementing herself into a position of inequality.
John tells Jane she has admirable qualities, and proposes that she marry him and accompany him on his missionary work. But Jane's "heart is mute." She recognizes that she could never be happy as St. John's wife. She tells him she would only go to work in India as his sister.
I forgive him at the moment, and on the spot" (298). In Moor House, after her quarrel with St. John over their different understandings of marriage, Jane wishes to believe that he is "superior to the mean gratification of vengeance" and that "he had forgiven me for saying I scorned him and his love" (410).
Does St John fall in love with Jane
St John's marriage proposal to Jane is made without love and passion – he presents it as a job, not as a relationship. He is very cold when he describes how he feels about Jane, suggesting that she was formed for God's work and not for love, implying that no one will love her.As she is about to accept St. John's wishes, Jane experiences a sensation as "sharp, as strange, as shocking" as an electric shock. Then she hears Rochester's voice calling her name. So powerful is this voice that Jane cries, "I am coming," and runs out the door into the garden, but she discovers no sign of Rochester.Jane refuses to marry St. John because she does not love him, but St. John pressures Jane to ignore her feelings and submit to his powerful conception of necessary moral duty.
St John's marriage proposal to Jane is made without love and passion – he presents it as a job, not as a relationship. He is very cold when he describes how he feels about Jane, suggesting that she was formed for God's work and not for love, implying that no one will love her.
Why didn t Jane want to marry Rochester : She fears that Rochester would objectify her and that by “marrying above her station” she would come to the relationship already “in debt” to him. Now Jane sees more clearly than ever that a relationship with Rochester would mean the loss of her self-respect, and of her control over her life.
What is the age gap between Jane and Rochester : Rochester is 37, Jane Eyre is 18. This is even mentioned in the book as a major age gap (see chapter 36, "Mr. Rochester was about forty, and this governess not twenty; and you see, when gentlemen of his age fall in love with girls, they are often like as if they were bewitched. Well, he would marry her.").
What is the age difference between Jane Eyre and Rochester
Rochester is 37, Jane Eyre is 18. This is even mentioned in the book as a major age gap (see chapter 36, "Mr. Rochester was about forty, and this governess not twenty; and you see, when gentlemen of his age fall in love with girls, they are often like as if they were bewitched. Well, he would marry her.").
John is a dangerous influence on her, because his forceful personality compels her obedience against her own internal feelings. Jane refuses to marry St. John because she does not love him, but St. John pressures Jane to ignore her feelings and submit to his powerful conception of necessary moral duty.Rosamund Oliver
John does not love Jane. He wants to marry her just because he thinks she would make a good missionary's wife because of her intelligence,dedication and virtues. He loves Rosamund Oliver passionately,but doesn't want to marry her because he thinks she is unsuited for the work of a missionary's wife.
Should Jane have ended up with St John : It is simply not right for Jane to conjoin herself with such a force. Although her true love, Rochester, is at this stage not right for her either – he is still bound to his wife, and has much to atone for in his past before he can belong to Jane – it is clear that she cannot choose St. John Rivers.